Monday, November 24, 2008

The Bigger The Trough

…..the larger their snouts…..

The US auto companies didn’t quite get the warm political reception they’d hoped for as part of their grubbing for US25 billion. Given that all 3 claim to be on the verge of bankruptcy, it didn’t help their case that the CEOs arrived in private jets. In mitigation, General Motors is returning 3 of its leased jets while promising greater use of video conferencing…..

Oh, and being asked by politicians to spell out exactly why they need capital, what they intend to do with it, over what time frame and what kind of returns to expect, was hardly a surprise. Any SME, whether looking for factoring funds, seed capital, mezzanine financing, venture capital or a bank loan would be asked exactly the same questions. What gave the auto companies’ CEOs the temerity to think they’d be exempt from the basic criteria of accountability?

Probably the fact that to date neither the US Federal Reserve nor the Treasury will disclose exactly what securities they have accepted as part of the now scrapped “cash for trash” deal that was the original TARP. The new plan to directly take equity in the banks (and potentially anyone else) has already been derided as incipient nationalization and crony capitalism. Oversight provisions as to how the government funds will be dealt with once injected, are non-existent, other than a bland assumption that the funds will be deployed for lending.

Meanwhile, according to Calculated Risk, as of 21 November 2008, 22 US banks have failed this year – so far. In fairness, some banks in the US, particularly those that stayed well away from the financially engineered toxic debt instruments, are doing just fine and are happy to continue and extend lines of credit to well managed commercial clients.

And the boys at Citigroup – whose share price is now that of an enhanced penny stock - are working overtime negotiating a government bailout or a sell off (of their lucrative credit card business, the Smith Barney brokerage, or their recently appointed CEO Vikram Pandit who announced jobs cuts totalling 82,000).

The joys of being an international conglomerate like Citigroup, allow for a degree of self-righteousness flatly denied to private companies: Citi is too big too fail and must be “saved” to end the hysteria; as a US company operating all over the world overseas governments should help bail it out; Citi is a victim of short sellers whose stock price has a reached a level that necessitates government intervention by way of cash injection, absorption of bad loans and an assisted merger.

Um… OK… government intervention for whose benefit? The shareholders or the financial system?

© 2008 Sanjeev Aaron Williams All Rights Reserved

No comments: