Sticking It To Shareholders

One of the by-products of the Bear Stearns “rescue” was the destruction of shareholders wealth. Forget the fact that the office building was worth US1 Billion; forget the fact that book value was apparently US80.00 per share; forget the fact that it’s share price fell 47% real quick. At the end of the day, when debt levels are officially “toxic” and cash flow is negative, the company was worth about US2.00 a share.

It’s worth remembering that Bear Stearns had a policy of actively encouraging employee share ownership. 30% of the company was owned by its employees, many of whom were subject to lock-up agreements as to when they could sell their shares. The point is now moot. Their shares are worthless. Ironically, this was the result of the company being deemed too important to fail.

Further, according to a report on Bloomberg TV today aired in Hong Kong, Bear Stearns had US50 - 60 Billion in liquid assets. Really? What took them so long to wake up and turn them into cash? After all, it was in August 2007 that they first reported that 2 of their hedge funds with exposure to mortgage derivatives, were in trouble.

For SMEs the sobering lesson is the fundamental importance of cash flow and liquidity. SMEs are notoriously lax in monitoring cash flow especially from their Receivables. In fact, look at the Accounts Receivables Ageing Report of an SME and it’s often shocking just how many Receivables are outstanding for more than 90 days or worse, more than 120 days.

Whilst they may be presently listed on the Balance Sheet as Current Assets and potentially liquid, the longer they remain outstanding, the greater the risk that they will turn toxic. In time, the Accountants will advise the company to shift those Receivables further down the Balance Sheet to Bad Debt. In other words, those Receivables are written off. The Invoice, which should have generated cash, is now a worthless debt instrument. Effectively, it’s no different to the massive writedowns witnessed on Wall Street from flakey mortgage backed securities. In either case, the cash flow is crippled.

SMEs don’t have the luxury of US Federal Reserve bail outs. The crippling of cash flow results in an erosion of shareholder equity. Yes, you can be profitable, and at the same time you can be insolvent. That’s the lesson Wall Street is now learning to its huge embarrassment.

And if the SME has lousy cash flow, is technically insolvent, is saddled with Bad Debts and has no other liquidity options, the Directors, who are usually the major shareholders, are holding potentially worthless shares.

© 2008 Sanjeev Aaron Williams All Rights Reserved